I disagree with Daniel Cotter’s essay i The Des Moines Register urging our U.S. Senators to reject Steven Menashi’s nomination to the U.S. Court of Appeals. (See link below to Register “Your Turn” essay.) What I’ve learned by watching Steven Menashi’s Senate testamony and reading his writings makes me think he would be a very good appellate judge.The fact that the two Democratic Senators from his home state of New York don’t support him should be considered irrelevant, regardless of precedent. The Senate “blue slip” tradition which permitted a Senator from the home state of the nominee to veto the nomination, is the remnant of a good-ol’-boy’s-club attitude that should be discarded.His opponents take his comments out of context and make them appear to have the opposite meaning of his actual position. For example, nine years ago he wrote that it was okay for Israel, a democratic country, to have an official state sanctioned dominant religion. The Left says this means he is a white supremacist. No, he is simply a defender of Israel’s right to exist, and of the right of the people of that nation to decide how they will be self-ruled. He testified before the Senate that the United States is not a country that is based on a single religious or ethnic tradition. He also testified that he values our, “…country’s tradition of tolerance and equality before the law…”So, I ask Senators Grassley and Ernst to support the nomination of Steven Menashi to the U.S. Court of Appeals.
Link to essay in The Des Moines Register: https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/opinion/columnists/2019/10/15/2nd-circuit-nominee-steven-menashi-one-trumps-most-radical-picks/3983913002/